New Finding: In 49 Australian Industries the Major Firms Are Owned by Common Investors

New Finding: In 49 Australian Industries the Major Firms Are Owned by Common Investors

New Finding: In 49 Australian Industries the Major Firms Are Owned by Common Investors

By Australian National Review

In more than a fifth of Australia’s industries, the two biggest firms control at least half the market.

Think of telecommunications, supermarkets, department stores, packaging, airlines, hardware, service stations, cinema chains and commercial television.

In industries like these there’s a temptation to share the spoils — not to compete too hard on price or service.

How much stronger would that temptation be if both dominant firms in each industry were owned by the same shareholder or set of shareholders?

Neither firm might want to put the other out of business.

There’s evidence to suggest this has indeed been the case in the United States where increases in common ownership have been linked to higher airline fares, more expensive pharmaceuticals, and higher bank fees.

It’s enough to make you wonder whether there’s common ownership in Australia.

Competitors share owners

To find out, Andrew Leigh and I collected data from IBISWorld on the firms that compete with each other across Australia’s 443 industries.

We then matched that data to shareholding disclosures for each of the firms listed on the share market and analysed the extent to which competitors were owned by the same investors.

Our findings, just published in Economic Record, are troubling.

They identify common ownership in 49 of Australia’s 443 industries.

They are significant industries. The 49 together account for more than one third of Australia’s total industry revenue.

They include commercial banking, explosives manufacturing, fuel retailing, general insurance and iron ore mining.

In firms in those industries in which we can identify at least one owner, 31% share a substantial owner with a rival.

Concentration is bigger than it looks

Market concentration is traditionally measured by the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI) on a scale in which an HHI of less than 1,500 is considered to be competitive, an HHI of 1,500 to 2,500 is considered to be a moderately concentrated, and an HHI of 2,500 or more to be a highly concentrated.

When we modified the HHI to take account of common ownership, the scores of some industries jumped.

The index for banking jumped from 1,534 to 5,850; the index for funds management services jumped from 1,254 to 3,014. The index for department stores jumped from 3,061 to 4,888.

Common Ownership of Competing Firms: Evidence from Australia

All up, effective market concentration was 20% higher than had been thought.

This is a problem because concentrated markets have been linked to a decline in the labour share of income, low productivity growth and low investment, as well as high prices, markups and rising inequality — all challenges Australia is facing.

Who are these common owners? They are overwhelmingly institutional investors, predominantly BlackRock and Vanguard.

This is unsurprising given one of either BlackRock, Vanguard or State Street is the largest shareholder in 88% of S&P500 companies in the United States.

BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street

But do they influence corporate decisions? The literature suggests they do.

Documenting the channels through which common owners affect competition, Nathan Shekita identifies 30 cases of common owner intervention across industries including pharmaceuticals, oil and gas, banking and ride-sharing.

In 2019 BlackRock engaged 2,050 times with 1,458 companies in 42 markets.

Martin Schmalz provides a case study of how this can occur.

An activist hedge fund campaigned in 2015 to have DuPont take a more aggressive approach to winning market share from its competitor, Monsanto.

The campaign was opposed by institutional investors including BlackRock and Vanguard. Upon the news that the activist campaign against DuPont had been defeated, Monsanto’s shares rose 3.5%.

Schmalz believes it’s possible that these institutional investors voted to maximise the value of their entire portfolio, which included significant stakes in DuPont’s competitor.

Our own study has plenty of limitations. We can only see Australian firms that are listed on the securities exchange, we can only observe shareholdings that exceed 5%, we can only see the largest competitors.

These data limitations mean we might have understated common ownership.

Our findings ought to be enough to get policymakers and regulators looking more deeply into common ownership and monitoring its changes.

Only if we “follow money” can we get a true account of what that money does.

Original Source:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Comments

27 Sep 22
For children and adults with normal immune status, routine booster doses of HepB vaccine are not really helpful. By controlling replication, we will management the variety of cells being administered to a affected person, which limits affected person-to-patient variability. There is a difference between miner- als which are within the floor verses minerals in vegetation antibiotic bladder infection purchase discount colcitrat line. If a conductive deafness is present, the tone might be heard extra distinctly in the deafer ear. It could be: Small bowel and omentum the most common Large bowel appendix the bladder Reducible herniawhen the protruded viscus could be returned again to the stomach Irreducible herniawhen the contents can t be returned again Obstructed herniathe content of the hernia (intestine) is occluded but no impairment of vascular provide Strangulated herniawhen the vascularity of protruded viscus is impaired Richter's herniawhen just one aspect of the wall of the gut is herniated. Both included Low issues: (121 patients) research and an current systematic (High study Miscarriage review supported no distinction in limitations, 1 Obs254 (499,a hundred thirty five miscarriage infantile spasms youtube generic 200mg urispas. The injuries must be backbone might suffer neurologic deterioration during closed investigated using a range of imaging modalities, together with discount in the presence of an associated herniated disc. This is due to the fact that every time there is a drawback with the liver, the stomach is also affected. Even in sufferers 5 who've a bruit, if no other threat components exist, the incidence is simply 2% erectile dysfunction treatment orlando generic viagra jelly 100 mg on-line. Description of selected opposed reactions Injection website reactions In the pivotal managed trials in adults and children, 12. Oxygen-mediated myocardial damage during ischaemia and reperfusion: role of the cellular defences towards oxygen toxicity. Intraoperative ultrasound is a helpful adjunct to locate the node in horizontal and vertical planes to be able to guide incision placement and limit pointless dissection acne information cheap generic isoacne canada. A chromosomal karyotype is indicated for all quick statured women who're delayed (for possible Turner syndrome) and for boys who're tall with small gentle testes with or with out delayed sexual maturity (Klinefelter's syndrome). Protective measures to guard personnel from exposures to these aerosols ought to be integrated into the laboratory Standard Operating Procedures. Early tracheal intubation ought to be considered by somebody skilled within the approach pain treatment for tennis elbow buy cheap aleve 500 mg line. This con tion of a prototype fngerprint reader to refect the experi tract was for a device to routinely locate and decide ence gained from the original demonstration models with the relative position and orientation of the specifed trivialities an additional requirement for velocity and accuracy. If solely a textual content report is on the market, use: final prognosis, microscopic, or gross examination, in that order. You should learn about the topic and apply the rules to your individual circumstances to develop your own personal coping methods infection preventionist salary sumamed 250mg on line.